In
a recent Op/Ed column from The New York Times, authors Todd and
Victoria Buccholz have deemed my demographic (the young, unemployed or
underemployed college graduates) as “The Go-Nowhere Generation”—a
moniker that, at first glance, I would agree with. At first glance.
The
vast majority of us, perhaps the ones hit hardest by the economic
recession, have been saddled with crippling college and credit card
debt and are forced to either scrounge for scraps amongst the Baby
Boomers or hide out in higher education; hoping to god that we'll
graduate during a time when a Master's degree or a PhD will actually
mean something again. Getting a job in this economy means you either
got really lucky (really
lucky) or you knew someone who was able to pull some strings for you.
No longer are we evaluated on the merits of our education or fields
of study, the summer internships or how well we're able to
communicate and convince our passion for industry XYZ in our cover
letters. And for a generation of “Go-Nowheres” who, since birth
were instilled with the notion that a promising future was ours if we
did well in school, this particular jobs climate is both morally
degrading and emotionally debilitating.
So
when a couple of assholes continue to enjoy the view from their ivory
towers, I get a little annoyed. And when these certain assholes
start spouting off economic “strategies” that are so inherently
flawed, unrealistic and categorically untrue, I'm flipping tables.
Because according to the Buchholz pair, those who have been scouring
the ends of the earth for steady employment for years simply never
thought of just buying a bus ticket:
“For about $200, young Nevadans who face a statewide 13% jobless rate can hop a Greyhound bus to North Dakota, where they'll find a welcome sign and a 3.3 percent rate. Why are young people not crossing borders?”
Young
people aren't leaving their parents' houses and crossing borders
because, with mounting debt and no job to pay it off, they don't have
the finances to move to North Dakota... or anywhere outside the
radius of their parents' basement. Mystery solved.
But,
whatever; I'll play along and, for a second, I'll pretend that the
Buchholz's total delusions and band-aid solutions for economic
recovery are even a fraction feasible for this particular climate.
Say I did buy that ticket. And now, after up and leaving likely the
only real support system I have and spending a couple hundred dollars
on a bus ticket to a state that's vastly underpopulated (which, in
addition to the population's majority of retired senior citizens,
directly accounts for its low unemployment rate), I have to find an
apartment to live in. With an apartment comes first and last month's
rent, security deposit, utilities, and possible pet boarding fees.
Totally ignoring the exorbitant costs of renting and driving a UHAUL
while paying $4/gallon for gas to transport my things, I'm still
faced with the dilemma of finding a job. Competing (once again) with
hundreds of others in a similar position, based on the selection of admin work in the entire state of North Dakota, I'm now fending for a
temporary P/T mail room clerk position in Gwinner or an HVAC design
estimator in Bismarck. WORTH IT!
Total inanity and oversimplification aside, though, what bothers me most about this article is that, once again, it insinuates (if not overstates) that young people are just entitled, lazy brats who are somehow at fault for not being able to contribute to the world, despite the total deck of manure we were dealt with in this lifetime. And what makes matters so much worse is that we're constantly having to listen to a condescending older generation who—light-years away from ever Getting It—write and publish articles like these that completely undermine the painstaking efforts we go through just to get an interview. It's baffling that this particular generation has completely forgotten the fact that they lived during a very different time in this country where a college education didn't cost a small fortune and that a secure job was guaranteed to them after graduation. Last time I checked, the recession happened because a board room full of multi-millionaires got just a little bit more greedy and set into motion a ticking time-bomb to profit off of at the very real expense of others. It wasn't a 22 year-old college graduate who, after seeing the way the world really works and after dealing with the pyramid scheme of a totally useless college degree, got a little apathetic and disheartened along the way.
We're
the “Go-Nowhere Generation” because it's the same economic
climate everywhere. There's nowhere to go. At least at home,
there's familiar ground and familial support to help us through it.
We're not moving around because we don't have the finances from being
crippled by student loans and tuition debt from colleges that lied to
us about our job prospects. We're not moving around because we live
in an economy that won't hire us as more and more college graduates
are churned out each year. And, based on the astronomical cost of living,
we're not able to suffice or start families of our own on the wages
of waitressing well into our late-twenties and early-thirties.
Stop
blaming us, assholes.
What a completely ridiculous, clueless article. You think we "older" people (I'm 50) had it easy compared to you? I've got news for you, Courtney. Uh, no. A LOT of us graduated with debt equal to yours in today's dollars. A LOT of us couldn't find good work right away - my first job in 1986 AFTER I GRADUATED FROM COLLEGE WITH A B.A. paid a whopping $11,000 a year, basically minimum wage at the time - but we kept at it. We didn't whine about how life was so "unfair." My brother 10 years ago had NOTHING. He worked his rear-end off, working three jobs and 80 hours a week, and saved his money. Today he owns six restaurants and a convenience store. Are you willing to work 80 hours a week, Courtney, doing ANYTHING (and by the way, there ARE jobs right now, everywhere, if you really want to work! Our area in southern South Carolina is begging for fast-food management trainees right now.)? Are you willing to work 80 hours a week, even if it means minimum wage? Don't tell me that's not available, because it is. How bad do you want it? Your generation doesn't get it. My wife is a hiring manager with a major corporation that is CONSTANTLY HIRING, and she tells me your fellow 20-somethings are more concerned with how much time off they'll get and wondering why they have to be to work on time. Your article, frankly, (I was going to say disgusts) disappoints me greatly, because it's so wrong on so many levels. You don't get it. And you're welcome to e-mail me at markga123@yahoo.com if you want to continue this conversation. - Mark in S. Carolina
ReplyDeleteUnfortunately sir, although I agree with you on the entitlement disease that has afflicted this new generation, college graduates have been lied to. You're told to work your ass off in high-school, those who end their education there tend to work in the labor sector. Those who go to college are told that once the graduate, the "white, picket fence" is waiting for them. This is simply not true. The American Dream is dead. Things HAVE changed since 1986. Not to say that there isn't a lot of unwarranted bitching, complaining, etc. But the statistics say it all. THIS is the prelude to the end of the world. Get it right or pay the price. Open your eyes man!
DeleteAnd your lack of civility towards a young woman is disturbing. You may and should stand up for your beliefs, but be a gentleman about it. As humans we should be better than that.
DeleteHi Mark,
DeleteThanks for reading. I certainly believe (and will concede) that there are plenty of people out there—both young and old—who unfortunately have taken advantage of this economy and it's a shame. Even some of my employed friends will sound off about how rude and unprofessional some of their co-workers are. It's pretty frustrating to hear about. I would suspect that those people are the ones who've given everyone else a bad name and incite authors to write these types of Op/Ed columns and for you to “disgustedly” respond. But I would argue that there are many more—again, both young and old—who are foaming at the mouth to work and I'm certainly one of them.
My article was certainly not meant to personally offend you, but to highlight a larger problem that I (and others) have come across. Present company excluded, it's exceedingly difficult to try and make those who have been fortunate enough not to experience the fall-out effects of this recession know the kind of mental and emotional toll it takes on you. Currently, I'm waiting to hear back from a job across the country that could honestly change my life—one that, through hard work and determination, I feel as though I've earned. As you probably know, there's a big difference between earned and entitled to, Mark, and since graduating from college, I've left that bubble and learned that I'm not entitled to anything. But I have earned the right to join the workforce (or at least the chance to) and the right to pursue a future much like you and your generation had before us.
I do hope that you'll continue reading this blog and voice your criticisms and concerns. Hearing a dissenting, but valid viewpoint is incredibly educational and helpful for me as I continue to contribute to Prelude to the End of the World.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDear Readers,
DeletePlease know that this deleted comment was my own in mistakenly not hitting reply to Anonymous 6:31 pm (you can read my response above). I will not delete or censor anyone's opinions or commentary on this blog.
You better not...or else.
DeleteI honestly think the problem here is too many people are getting degrees that are pretty much worthless (to the market, obviously not the person getting the degree), and burying themselves in debt in the process. Unemployment for scientists, computer programmers, engineers, nurses etc is extremely low, and always will be. When you get a shit primary education that teaches math and physics in a way only the most sadistic students can enjoy, you end up with a ton of liberal arts majors, and communication majors that will have a very difficult time finding a job.
ReplyDeleteI think that over the past 30 years many of the basic professions these people entered the workforce into were replaced by machines or moved overseas. At the same time more and more students were told to go to college and pursue a degree that resembles more of a passion or hobby than a worthwhile $100K expense. Couple that with the financial crisis which halted hiring and you have a trifecta of doom.
I don't mean to preach or say that only people that get science degrees should go to college. But I do notice that all of my friends that have a science degree, or a nursing degree, have a job and are making a good living, while a large percentage of my friends with liberal arts degrees are out of work or underemployed. I am also not saying to give up on a passion or NOT to study it in college. But people should consider dual majors, auditing classes, free online video classes and other new innovations where they can explore their passion for the arts, or woman's studies, or literature without spending a shit load of money. For a lot of these degrees the cost-benefit-ratio does not work out and you unfortunately are setting yourself up for a tough, uphill battle.
Well put, sir. Liberal Arts degrees are the kiss of death these days. I should know, I almost completed one before realizing how senseless it would be. Now I have a job in a kitchen which pays the bills while also continue to pursue my passion for writing. It's a strange viewpoint when many friends who DID graduate college can't find work while I dropped out and have always had a job. It's certainly not something I hope to make a career of, but at the moment it works. Excellent insight. Hope you'll comment more.
Delete